Mediators or Alternative Explanations: Transitivity in Human-Mediated Causal Chains
نویسنده
چکیده
We investigate how learning that an established type-level causal relationship is implemented by human agency affects people’s conceptualization of this relationship. In particular, we ask under what conditions subjects continue to perceive the original root cause as appropriate explanation for the resulting effect, and under what conditions they perceive the mediating intentional action as alternative explanation instead. Using a new experimental paradigm, we demonstrate that mechanisms involving intentional action lead to intuitions of causal intransitivity, but only when these actions are norm-violating. Potential generalizations and implications for scientific theory construction are discussed.
منابع مشابه
A Transitivity Heuristic of Probabilistic Causal Reasoning
In deterministic causal chains the relations „A causes B’ and „B causes C’ imply that „A causes C’. However, this is not necessarily the case for probabilistic causal relationships: A may probabilistically cause B, and B may probabilistically cause C, but A does not probabilistically cause C, but rather ¬C. The normal transitive inference is only valid when the Markov condition holds, a key fea...
متن کاملCauses of causes
When is a cause of a cause of an effect also a cause of that effect? The right answer is either “Sometimes” or “Always”. In favour of “Always”, transitivity is considered by some to be necessary for distinguishing causes from redundant noncausal events. Moreover transitivity may be motivated by an interest in an unselective notion of causation, untroubled by principles of invidious discriminati...
متن کاملCausal Networks or Causal Islands? The Representation of Mechanisms and the Transitivity of Causal Judgment
Knowledge of mechanisms is critical for causal reasoning. We contrasted two possible organizations of causal knowledge—an interconnected causal network, where events are causally connected without any boundaries delineating discrete mechanisms; or a set of disparate mechanisms—causal islands—such that events in different mechanisms are not thought to be related even when they belong to the same...
متن کاملExplanatory Completeness: Evidence from Causal Chains
Explanations have no bound in principle, but in practice, people prefer explanations that are complete (Zemla et al., 2017), and the explanations that they generate are bounded (Miyake, 1986). We tested reasoners’ ability to assess whether some explanations are incomplete. Participants in three experiments received explanations, i.e., chains of causal events, e.g., A causes B causes C. Their ta...
متن کاملStijn Vansteelandt Mediation Analysis with Multiple Mediators
Recent advances in the causal inference literature on mediation have extended traditional approaches to direct and indirect effects to settings that allow for interactions and non-linearities. In this article, these approaches from causal inference are further extended to settings in which multiple mediators may be of interest. Two analytic approaches, one based on regression and one based on w...
متن کامل